Ohio Attorney General Cries Foul on Wine.com and Other Wine Retailers

The state's attorney general is attempting to use a 21st Amendment power to stop direct deliveries from out-of-state retailers, raising new questions about Ohio's alcohol shipping laws

Ohio Attorney General Cries Foul on Wine.com and Other Wine Retailers
Ohio attorney general Dave Yost argues that out-of-state wine retailers are hurting Ohio wine merchants and depriving the state of sales tax revenue. (Photo by Justin Merriman/Getty Images)
Jul 20, 2020

Ohio has declared war on several out-of-state wine merchants. Attorney general Dave Yost has filed a request in federal court seeking an injunction against multiple online wine and liquor retailers from other states, alleging that they have been illegally shipping wine directly to Ohio consumers. Under the Buckeye State's shipping laws, consumers can only order wine from in-state merchants. The sellers named in the injunction include Wine.com, Winc, Pacific Wine & Spirits, Cocktail Courier and Wine Country Gift Baskets, among others. Yost announced last week that he intends to halt the shipments via injunction and the rarely exercised 21st Amendment Enforcement Act.

"We are not aware of any other [attorney general] who has sued using the 21st Amendment Enforcement Act," David O'Neil, a spokesperson for Yost's office, told Wine Spectator via email. The act permits state attorneys general to bring a civil action against any person believed to be violating their state's laws on importing and transporting alcohol.

According to a statement from Yost's office, investigators with Ohio's Division of Liquor Control gathered evidence in May to file an injunction by using pseudonyms to successfully purchase products from the named sellers, having them shipped to the division's offices. The investigators also reviewed common-carrier shipping reports for evidence of alcohol being sent from out of state. "It's safe to say tens of thousands [of illegal shipments] take place every year," O'Neil alleged, noting that Yost's office believes such sales have been ongoing for many years.


Where can you order wine from? Check out Wine Spectator's comprehensive guide to state shipping laws.


Yost says that these allegedly illegal sales are not properly taxed and take business away from in-state retailers. Pete Minotti, who owns three wine and spirits stores in Ohio, echoed that sentiment. "I'd like to keep all of the wine and liquor business that is available in Ohio, in Ohio," he said.

Other voices in the U.S. retail sector say the legal maneuver punishes Ohio consumers. Tom Wark, executive director of the National Association of Wine Retailers, a pro-shipping group, argues that the ban on out-of-state shipments hinders Ohioans from purchasing bottles they're unable to find in local stores. "No one is harmed by consumers purchasing and receiving wine from out-of-state retailers," he said. "If Ohio is concerned with collecting tax revenue on wine sales," said Wark, "the best way of doing so is to create a legal path for out-of-state retailers to ship wine to Ohioans that also requires the remittance of sales taxes."

Wark also points out that Yost has received campaign donations from Ohio alcohol wholesalers, who oppose shipping by out-of-state retailers.

Chicago-based lawyer Sean O'Leary, who has participated in several cases involving wine and interstate commerce, argues that Ohio's shipping laws are unconstitutional. "Ohio's law discriminates against out-of-state wine retailers in violation of the Dormant Commerce Clause," he said, "[Its] law allows its own retailers to ship to Ohio customers and does not allow out-of-state retailers this same privilege."

The Ohio attorney general’s injunction request comes just three months after the Sixth Circuit Court's Lebamoff Enterprises v. Whitmer decision, which ruled that Michigan may permit in-state shipments while prohibiting out-of-state deliveries. That decision is being appealed in light of a monumental Supreme Court decision in 2019. In Tennessee Wine and Spirits Retailers Association v. Russell F. Thomas, the country’s highest court found that states’ 21st Amendment rights do not trump laws barring economic protectionism if no legitimate alcohol-regulation purpose is served.


Stay on top of important wine stories with Wine Spectator's free Breaking News Alerts.


According to O'Leary, the Ohio attorney general’s office may become increasingly assertive by looking into carrier records and taking more legal action against suspected violators. If Ohio succeeds, other states may follow suit. "But keep in mind there will be pushback, and this is not an open-and-shut case," O'Leary said. "[It] also allows consumers to challenge Ohio's shipping laws as discriminatory."

Constitutional questions aside, at least two of the online retailers have indicated that they will cooperate with the state. Rich Bergsund, CEO of Wine.com, told Wine Spectator that the company is now working in good faith with Yost's office to resolve the issue.

Executives at Winc believe their company was incorrectly named in Yost's lawsuit, as it has paid taxes to the state and holds all permits necessary to send wine into Ohio. "We look forward to resolving this matter with the Ohio attorney general's office as quickly as possible," said Tracey Bakun, the company's brand manager, "so that we can continue to serve Ohioans for years to come."

News Direct Shipping Legal and Legislative Issues Collecting United States

You Might Also Like

Williams Selyem Owners Sell Stake in Winery to Burgundy's Faiveley Family

Williams Selyem Owners Sell Stake in Winery to Burgundy's Faiveley Family

Faiveley family’s minority stake positions them to potentially take over one of Sonoma's …

Jan 15, 2021
Stone Barns Center Kicks Off Rotating Chef Residencies

Stone Barns Center Kicks Off Rotating Chef Residencies

In its first season, the reimagined concept will host four eclectic chefs for five weeks …

Jan 14, 2021
Vall Llach's Cellar Roof Collapses Under Record Snow in Spain, Jeopardizing 3 Vintages of Wine

Vall Llach's Cellar Roof Collapses Under Record Snow in Spain, Jeopardizing 3 Vintages of Wine

Two feet of snow fell on Priorat; owners have not been able to enter the building and see …

Jan 13, 2021
Restaurant Award Winners That Have Permanently Closed During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Restaurant Award Winners That Have Permanently Closed During the COVID-19 Pandemic

A running list of wine-focused dining spots that have been forced to shut for good as the …

Jan 13, 2021
SND: Gallo Closes Mega-Deal with Constellation Brands

SND: Gallo Closes Mega-Deal with Constellation Brands

Two wine industry giants exchange more than 30 wine brands for $810 million

Jan 7, 2021
U.S. Government Decides Not to Redefine Moderate Wine Drinking

U.S. Government Decides Not to Redefine Moderate Wine Drinking

The new federal dietary guidelines kept the recommendation that men drink no more than two …

Jan 6, 2021